Reshingle Roof Estimate: What a Written Quote Should Cover

Roofing advice from a family owned Pittsburgh roofing company.

  • Five star Google reviews
  • BBB A+ rated
  • AtlasPro+ Platinum Select
  • PA HIC# PA174918
Atlas Morning Harvest roof, start to finish by Malick Brothers Exteriors in Allison Park
November 15, 2026

Two estimates to reshingle the same roof can look very different, and it is not always because one roofer is cheaper. Often the lower quote simply leaves things out: decking, flashing, ventilation or cleanup. A clear written estimate shows exactly what you are paying for.

Here is what a complete reshingle estimate should cover, so you can compare quotes fairly before you commit to roof replacement in Pittsburgh.

Tear Off or Roof Over?

Old shingles removed and new underlayment going down on a Pittsburgh home by Malick Brothers

The estimate should say whether the old shingles come off. A full tear off is usually the better choice because it exposes the deck so damaged boards can be replaced, and it avoids adding weight to the roof.

Pennsylvania building code limits how many layers a roof can have, so a home that already has two layers needs a tear off no matter what.

A full tear off lets the crew see and fix the deck before new shingles go on.

Decking and Hidden Damage

No one can see every bad board until the shingles are off. A good estimate explains how rotted or soft decking will be handled if the crew finds it, so there are no surprises halfway through the job.

Ask how damaged decking is measured and replaced. Clear terms up front protect both you and the contractor.

Underlayment going down over a sound deck on a Malick job.

Crew installing underlayment on a Pittsburgh roof deck by Malick Brothers

Line Items a Complete Estimate Includes

These are the pieces that separate a complete reshingle quote from a bare one.

1

Underlayment

The layer between the deck and shingles. The estimate should name the product, not just say underlayment.

2

Flashing

Step flashing, chimney flashing, valley metal and pipe boots should be listed as new or reused.

3

Ventilation

Ridge vents, intake vents and any upgrades should be spelled out.

4

Cleanup and disposal

Removal of old shingles, a dumpster and a magnetic sweep for nails belong in the quote.

Shingle Brand, Line and Warranty

Malick Brothers crew working on a roof replacement in the Pittsburgh area

A vague line like architectural shingles is not enough. The estimate should name the manufacturer and product line, the color and the warranty that comes with it.

We install complete Atlas roof systems, with Atlas shingles, underlayment and ventilation. Because we are Atlas Platinum Pro+, we can offer Atlas's 50 year warranty on those complete systems. Ask any contractor which warranty applies to your quote and what it covers.

Our crew mid job, with materials staged for a complete roof system.

Red Flags in a Roofing Quote

Be cautious with a quote that is a single number with no breakdown, pushes you to sign the same day or asks for full payment up front. Those are signs the contractor may not stand behind the work.

Also watch for estimates that skip the tear off on a roof that already has two layers, or say nothing about decking, flashing or ventilation. A low price that leaves out the parts that keep water out is not a bargain. A contractor who explains each line clearly is the one more likely to do the job right.

How the Roof Is Measured

A reshingle estimate starts with an accurate measurement. The roofer measures each slope and adds them together to get the total area in squares. The pitch of the roof matters too, because steeper roofs have more surface area than their footprint suggests and take more time and safety equipment to work on.

Valleys, hips, ridges, chimneys, skylights and dormers all add time and material. A simple gable roof is quicker to reshingle than a cut up roof with many angles, even if both cover the same house.

Some contractors measure by hand on the roof, others use aerial measurement. Either way, ask how many squares the estimate is based on so you can compare quotes on the same basis.

Timeline and What to Expect

Most reshingle jobs on a typical home take a day or two, depending on size, weather and how much decking needs work. The estimate or contract should give a rough timeline and explain what happens if weather delays the start.

Ask how the crew protects your property. Tarps over landscaping, plywood against walls and a magnetic sweep for nails at the end of each day are signs of a careful crew.

Finally, ask how the final walk through works. You should see the finished roof, confirm cleanup is done and receive warranty paperwork for the materials and workmanship.

Waste, Starter and Ridge Materials

The square count on an estimate is the roof area, but the material order is always a little larger. Every roof has cuts at valleys, hips, rakes and around chimneys and skylights, and the pieces trimmed off are waste. A simple gable roof has little waste. A roof with many valleys and dormers has much more.

Starter shingles along the eaves and rakes and ridge cap shingles along the peaks and hips are separate products. A complete estimate lists them instead of folding them into a general shingle line, so you know they are not being skipped or replaced with cut field shingles.

Ask how much waste the estimate allows and whether starter and ridge cap are from the same manufacturer as the shingles. On a complete system, they usually need to be for the warranty to apply.

Edge, Valley and Leak Barrier Details

Some of the most important parts of a reshingle job are at the edges and in the valleys, where water collects and moves fastest. These items are easy to leave out of a quote, so look for each one by name.

1

Drip edge

Metal along the eaves and rakes that guides water into the gutters and protects the deck edge. It should be listed as new.

2

Leak barrier

A self sealing membrane at the eaves, in valleys and around penetrations. Pittsburgh winters make this layer especially important at the roof edge.

3

Valley method

Valleys can be open with metal, closed cut or woven. The estimate should say which method will be used.

4

Wall and chimney flashing

Step flashing and counter flashing where the roof meets walls and chimneys. Reusing old, rusted pieces is a common shortcut.

Payment Terms and Changes in Writing

A clear estimate also explains how the business side of the job works. It should state when payments are due, what triggers each one and how the final payment is tied to the finished work and your final walk through.

It should also explain how changes are handled. If the crew finds rotted decking, a soft area around a chimney or a layer of shingles nobody expected, you should know how that will be measured, how you will be told and how it will be approved before the work goes ahead.

Finally, the estimate or contract should include the company name, address and Pennsylvania home improvement contractor registration number. Malick Brothers is registered as PA HIC PA174918, and any contractor you hire should list theirs.

Questions to Ask Before You Sign

Before signing, ask who will do the work, how long the job will take, how the yard and landscaping will be protected and how payment is scheduled. Confirm the contractor is registered as a home improvement contractor in Pennsylvania and carries insurance. Our PA HIC number is PA174918.

Related reading: what a new roof should include and tear off or roof over.

Reshingle Estimate FAQs

How many estimates should I get?

Two or three is usually enough to compare scope, materials and warranty side by side.

Why do roofing estimates vary so much?

Most differences come from scope. One quote may include decking, flashing and ventilation while another leaves them out.

Is a free roof estimate really free?

With us, yes. We inspect the roof and give you a written estimate with no obligation.

How long is a roofing estimate good for?

Most estimates are good for a set period because material prices change. The written estimate should say how long it holds.

Should the estimate include permits?

Yes. If your town requires a permit for roof replacement, the estimate should say who pulls it and whether the cost is included. Permit rules vary between townships and boroughs around Pittsburgh, so ask your contractor how it works where you live.

What is the difference between a roofing estimate and a contract?

An estimate describes the work and materials the roofer recommends. A contract is the signed agreement that commits both sides to that scope, along with payment terms, the expected start date, how changes are approved and the warranties. In Pennsylvania, home improvement contracts must be in writing, so read the final contract closely before signing.

Get a Written Reshingle Estimate From Malick Brothers

We will inspect your roof and give you a clear written estimate that spells out every part of the job.

Malick Brothers Exteriors is a family owned roofing and exterior contractor at 500 Perry Highway in the North Hills, rated 4.9 on more than 350 Google reviews. Contact us or call (412) 616-0191 to schedule a free inspection and written estimate.