Slate Roof Care: Keeping an Older Pittsburgh Slate Roof Sound

Roofing advice from a family owned Pittsburgh roofing company.

  • Five star Google reviews
  • BBB A+ rated
  • AtlasPro+ Platinum Select
  • PA HIC# PA174918
New roof installed by Malick Brothers Exteriors in the Pittsburgh area
November 22, 2026

Natural slate is one of the longest lasting roofing materials there is, and plenty of older homes in Pittsburgh still have their original slate. Most of the time, the slate itself outlives everything around it. The flashing, fasteners and gutters are what need attention.

Good slate roof care is mostly about catching those small failures early. It can keep a slate roof going for many more years and push back the day you need roof replacement in Pittsburgh.

Why Slate Roofs Need Different Care

Slate roof with copper flashing on an older Pittsburgh home

Slate is hard and brittle. It does not wear like asphalt, but it can crack when walked on or struck by a falling branch. Working on a slate roof takes the right tools and know how so one repair does not break three more slates.

The nails holding each slate can also rust out over time. When they go, slates slip out of place even though the stone is fine.

Natural slate with copper valleys and trim on an older Pittsburgh home.

What to Check on a Slate Roof

A yearly look, ideally from the ground with binoculars or by a roofer who knows slate, should cover these points.

1

Cracked or slipped slates

Look for gaps in the pattern or slates hanging lower than their neighbors.

2

Flashing

Valleys, chimneys and wall flashing often fail before the slate does.

3

Gutters and edges

Clogged or loose gutters can back water under the lowest courses.

4

Signs inside

Stains in the attic or top floor ceilings point to a leak that needs tracking.

Flashing Is Usually the Weak Point

On many slate roofs the leaks come from worn valley metal, chimney flashing or old patches made with tar. Replacing flashing with copper or another long lasting metal keeps it in step with the life of the slate.

Chimneys and steep valleys on older homes are where slate roofs usually leak.

Older brick home with a steep roof and chimneys in Pittsburgh

Do Not Walk on Slate

Steep roof on an older Pittsburgh area home

Walking on slate is the fastest way to crack it. Roofers who work on slate use ladders, hooks and roof jacks to spread their weight. Satellite installers, chimney sweeps and gutter cleaners should know this too.

If someone needs to get on your slate roof, ask how they plan to do it without walking the slate.

Steep older roofs need roofers who work from ladders and hooks, not by walking the surface.

Keep Gutters and Edges in Good Shape

On a slate roof, the gutters and roof edge matter just as much as on any other roof. Clogged or sagging gutters back water up under the lowest slates, and rotted fascia gives the edge nothing solid to hold.

Many older slate homes also have box gutters built into the roof edge. Those need regular checks because a failed liner can leak straight into the walls. Our repair division handles box gutters, including silicone coatings that seal worn liners.

Hiring the Right Roofer for Slate

Slate work is a specialty. A roofer who mainly installs asphalt shingles may not have the tools or experience to repair slate without causing more damage. Ask any contractor how they replace a broken slate, how they get on the roof and what they use for flashing.

Good slate repairs use matching slate, copper or other long lasting metal for flashing and fasteners, and techniques that hold each slate without visible nails or tar. Tar patches and mismatched materials are signs of a past repair that may need redoing.

A roofer who knows slate will also tell you honestly when the slate itself is wearing out, rather than recommending replacement on a roof that only needs flashing work.

How Slate Ages

Not all slate is the same. Harder slates can last for generations, while softer slates may start flaking and delaminating sooner. Signs of aging slate include flaking surface layers, a powdery look and slates that crumble when touched.

Weather plays a role too. Freeze and thaw cycles work into weak slate and split it over time.

When many slates on a roof show these signs, repairs become harder to justify, because each repair disturbs nearby slates that are also weak. That is when replacement, either with new slate or another material suited to the house, becomes the practical choice.

Cleaning Moss and Debris off Slate

Leaves, pine needles and moss collect in valleys, behind chimneys and along the lower courses of a slate roof. That debris holds water against the stone and the flashing, and in winter the trapped water freezes and pushes on the slates.

Debris should be cleared by hand or with a soft brush from a ladder or roof hooks, never by walking the roof. Moss can be loosened gently and treated with a cleaner made for slate. Avoid pressure washers and harsh chemicals. High pressure can crack slate and drive water under the pieces, and some chemicals damage the copper and metal flashing nearby.

Trimming branches that hang over the roof cuts down on debris and lets the slate dry after rain, which slows moss growth in the first place.

Snow Guards and Ridges

Slate is smooth, and snow can slide off it all at once. Snow guards are small metal brackets set into the roof to hold snow in place so it melts off slowly. They protect gutters, lower roofs, porches and people walking below. Older guards can rust or pull loose, so they belong on the yearly checklist.

The ridge is another spot to watch. Many slate roofs have ridge slates or metal ridge caps set in mortar or sealant that cracks with age. Loose ridge pieces let water in at the very top of the roof, where a leak can run a long way before it shows up inside.

What to Do If a Slate Roof Starts Leaking

Take photos of the stain inside and any slates you can see out of place from the ground. Put a bucket under active drips and move anything valuable out of the way. Do not climb onto the slate to look for the cause.

Call a roofer who works on slate as soon as you can. For an active leak, a temporary cover can protect the house until a proper repair is made with matching slate and metal. Quick action keeps water out of plaster ceilings and framing, which are often harder to fix than the roof itself. Keep notes on when the leak appears, such as during heavy rain, wind from one direction or melting snow, because that pattern helps the roofer find the source faster. Our repair division handles slate repairs across Pittsburgh, the North Hills and the South Hills.

Repair or Replace a Slate Roof?

If the slate itself is sound, repairs and flashing work are almost always worth it. Replacement comes up when many slates are soft, flaking or failing, or when the roof has been patched so many times that leaks keep coming back.

Related reading: slate roof repair in Pittsburgh and repair or replace a slate roof.

Slate Roof Care FAQs

How often should a slate roof be checked?

Once a year and after major storms is a good rhythm, especially on older roofs.

Can a single broken slate be replaced?

Yes. A roofer can remove the broken piece and slide in a matching slate without disturbing the rest.

Should moss be pressure washed off slate?

No. Pressure washing can damage slate. A gentle approach is safer, and a roofer can advise on what is needed.

Can slate and asphalt be mixed on one roof?

On some homes, lower slopes or additions use other materials, but slate repairs should use matching slate to keep the roof sound.

Can a slate roof be replaced with shingles?

Yes, many owners choose architectural shingles or a slate style shingle when slate is worn out. The decking may need work to suit shingles, and on historic homes some owners prefer to stay with slate. A roofer can walk you through both options.

Do snow guards damage a slate roof?

Not when they are installed correctly. Good snow guards are fastened beneath the slates or hooked in a way that does not crack the stone or leave open nail holes. Problems come from guards glued on with adhesive or fastened through the face of the slate. A slate roofer can tell you if existing guards are secure or need resetting.

Get Slate Roof Help From Malick Brothers

Our repair division handles slate roofs. We will check your slate and flashing and tell you what needs attention.

Malick Brothers Exteriors is a family owned roofing and exterior contractor at 500 Perry Highway in the North Hills, rated 4.9 on more than 350 Google reviews. Contact us or call (412) 616-0191 to schedule a free inspection and written estimate.