At Malick Brothers Exteriors, we know how much Pittsburgh’s businesses depend on reliable roofs. Our region’s weather is demanding—heavy snow, heavy rain, and wide temperature swings. That’s why property managers and business owners can’t risk downtime caused by roof failures. Choosing the Best Commercial Roofing Contractors in Pittsburgh isn’t just about finding a crew who can swing a hammer; it’s about selecting a partner who protects your investment and keeps your operations running smoothly.
We’re proud to say that our team consistently delivers that standard. Still, we believe in transparency. That’s why we want to highlight a few other well-known companies in the area, and then explain why we believe Malick Brothers is the right long-term partner for your commercial roofing needs.
Why commercial roofing requires more than just experience
Commercial roofing is complex. It’s not the same as residential work, where projects are smaller and often more straightforward. Large, flat, or low-slope roofs require detailed planning, strict adherence to safety standards, and long-term system design. A contractor has to think about drainage, energy efficiency, tenant schedules, and building codes—all while managing large crews and timelines.
That’s where we shine. At Malick Brothers, our processes are designed around business needs. From inspections and core cuts to detailed reports and lifecycle planning, our goal is simple: give owners clarity and confidence. When companies compare commercial roofing contractors Pittsburgh, we want them to see that difference immediately.
Exploring Top Commercial Roofing Options in Pittsburgh
There are several roofing companies in Pittsburgh that property owners often consider:
- MHI Roofing – A long-standing company with good reviews and customer service.
- Resnick Roofing & Contracting – Known for strong communication and craftsmanship.
- Buccos Roofing – Certified with premium materials, including synthetic slate.
- MY Pittsburgh Roofing – Highly rated for affordability and responsiveness.
- EAS Roofing – Offers a mix of roofing, skylights, and siding services.
These are solid organizations, and we respect the work they’ve done in our region. But when it comes to balancing technical expertise, communication, and long-term value, Malick Brothers Exteriors goes further.
Why Malick Brothers is the superior choice
Here’s where we set ourselves apart:
- Full system expertise – Our team works with TPO, PVC, EPDM, BUR, and coating systems. We don’t push one material; we recommend the right fit for your building.
- Lifecycle planning – We give you options: repair, restore, or replace. That way you can budget in 5- or 10-year horizons instead of scrambling at the last minute.
- Business-first scheduling – We stage projects to minimize disruption to tenants, customers, and staff.
- Transparency – Every proposal includes photos, diagrams, and itemized details. You’ll know exactly what’s being done and why.
When business leaders ask about the best commercial roofing company or need Pittsburgh roofing experts who can deliver results without surprises, we want to be the first call they make.
What is the average cost of a commercial roof?
Costs vary based on size, materials, tear-off needs, insulation requirements, and building access. As a benchmark, many Pittsburgh commercial roofs range from the mid-teens per square foot and up. For a small building, that might mean $30,000–$50,000. For larger facilities, costs can move into six figures.
At Malick Brothers, we don’t just throw out a number. We walk you through the condition of your roof and explain repair, restore, and replace scenarios. That way, you can compare upfront price against long-term value.
What is the best roofing for commercial buildings?
It depends on the building. TPO and PVC are popular for reflectivity and energy efficiency. EPDM is a proven rubber membrane that holds up well in our climate. BUR systems provide layered redundancy, and coatings extend the life of existing roofs.
Our role is to evaluate your building’s slope, mechanical layout, foot traffic, and budget. Then, we recommend the system that checks all the right boxes. That’s how we consistently outperform other names on the Best Commercial Roofing Contractors in Pittsburgh lists.
How to tell if a roofer is lying
Unfortunately, our industry has its share of bad actors. Watch out for these red flags:
- Vague proposals with no photos or detailed scope.
- Unrealistically low bids that don’t account for tear-off or insulation.
- Evasive answers about warranties or manufacturer credentials.
- High-pressure sales tactics.
Our philosophy is the opposite. We believe informed clients make the best decisions, which is why we always provide photos, clear scopes, and open communication.
Is $30,000 too much for a roof?
Sometimes yes, sometimes no. For a smaller coating or repair job, it may be more than necessary. But for a full tear-off with new insulation on a commercial building, $30,000 may not even cover the basics.
The question is not “too much,” but “what are you getting for it?” That’s why we break down every line item so owners know exactly where their money is going.
Your checklist for choosing a contractor
When reviewing the Best Commercial Roofing Contractors in Pittsburgh, make sure you:
- Ask for a moisture scan or core cuts.
- Review a roof plan with details marked.
- Request three options: repair, restore, replace.
- Confirm certifications and warranties.
- Align the work schedule with tenant operations.
This is our standard process. It’s also why our projects close on time and without hidden surprises.
Safety and quality control
Roofing work requires discipline. Our crews follow strict safety measures, including fall protection, daily inspections, and site cleanliness. Quality control is built into our process, from seam testing to photo documentation. If you’d like to learn more about system selection and standards, the National Roofing Contractors Association is an excellent resource.
A look at the competition vs. Malick Brothers
| Contractor | Strengths | Limitations compared to Malick Brothers |
|---|---|---|
| MHI Roofing | Longevity, customer service | Less emphasis on lifecycle planning |
| Resnick Roofing | Strong communication, good craftsmanship | Narrower focus on commercial projects |
| Buccos Roofing | Premium material expertise | Less versatility with low-slope systems |
| MY Pittsburgh Roofing | Affordable, responsive | Smaller commercial portfolio |
| EAS Roofing | Versatile exterior services | Roofing not always the primary focus |
Respect to each competitor—but when it comes to the mix of technical expertise, scheduling discipline, and lifecycle planning, Malick Brothers Exteriors rises to the top.
Final thoughts
Pittsburgh businesses deserve reliable roofs and reliable contractors. There are several good companies in the region, but if you’re looking for a partner who provides clarity, options, and accountability, Malick Brothers Exteriors is the team to trust.
We encourage you to also check out our feature on Top Roofing Companies in North Hills Pittsburgh 2025 to see how we compare.
About Malick Brothers Exteriors (Worthington note)
We’ve built our reputation across Pittsburgh and beyond. In communities like Worthington, we bring the same commitment to excellence. Whether it’s a repair to protect tenants or a system replacement designed for decades of performance, our process remains the same: scope clearly, execute with discipline, and close out with confidence.
Ready to get started? Contact us today at Malick Brother Exteriors or call (412) 616-0191. Let’s make sure your business has the roofing protection it deserves.
